Skip to main content

Extra Credit Podcast 43: What Q3 2026 Credit Trends Mean for Lenders

Consumer credit growth continued in Q3 2026, but the topline numbers don’t tell the whole story. More borrowers are falling behind even as balance-level delinquency remains relatively stable, creating an important distinction between the number of consumers experiencing stress and the dollars at risk. For lenders, that divergence makes it increasingly important to look beneath aggregate portfolio performance.

In this episode of Extra Credit, Andy Mederich joins Josh Turnbull and Craig LaChapelle to examine the latest credit industry trends across personal loans, credit cards, mortgages, auto loans and student lending. Their discussion explores how growth is shifting across risk tiers, why small-dollar personal loans are expanding and where emerging pressures could affect future credit performance.

The conversation also considers what lenders should watch as earlier credit score improvements moderate and portfolio outcomes depend more heavily on whom lenders market to, approve and serve.
 

Listeners will learn:

  • Why borrower-level and balance-level delinquency measures are moving in different directions and what each can reveal about future credit performance
  • How growth of small-dollar personal loans is changing the composition of the market, and the information lenders may need for underwriting
  • Why credit card issuers are extending growth further across the risk spectrum while limiting exposure through smaller starting lines
  • How changing interest rates may affect mortgage refinancing, HELOC payments and financially stretched FHA borrowers
  • What recent auto loan performance can obscure about affordability pressures and the performance of newer loan vintages
  • Which early indicators lenders should monitor as they prepare for 2027, including borrower delinquency, roll rates, HELOC utilization and small-loan performance

About our guests

Josh Turnbull

Josh Turnbull, Senior Vice President of Consumer Lending at TransUnion, is co-host of the Extra Credit podcast and provides insights on consumer lending, credit trends and market dynamics affecting financial institutions. Connect with Josh on LinkedIn.
 

Craig LaChapelle

Craig LaChapelle, Vice President of Financial Services Strategy at TransUnion, is co-host of the Extra Credit podcast and regularly analyzes consumer credit performance, lending strategies and emerging market trends. Connect with Craig on LinkedIn.
 

Andy Mederich

Andy Mederich, Vice President, Financial Services, runs business development for TransUnion’s auto and community financial institution lines of business. During the episode, he brings a client-focused perspective to the discussion and challenges the co-hosts to translate market findings into practical considerations for lenders. Connect with Andy on LinkedIn.
 

Conversation between TransUnion Extra Credit Podcast co-hosts Craig LaChapelle and Josh Turnbull and Andy Mederich, business development leader for TransUnion’s auto and community financial institution lines of business. Recorded October 29, 2026.

Editor's note: This transcript has been lightly edited for readability and clarity

Craig LaChapelle: Welcome everyone to the next episode of TransUnion's Extra Credit. Today, as we happen to do every quarter, we turn the mic over to one of our colleagues or customers to quiz us on recent quarterly credit market performance across all of the main consumer lines of business — auto, card, consumer lending and mortgage — that are reviewed in TransUnion's quarterly consumer insights reports. In this case, at the conclusion of Q3 2026.

So today we welcome Andy Mederich, one of TransUnion's client relationship leaders. Andy leads credit insights and solution sales to our largest auto customers and our CFI customers, and he's based in the Chicagoland area. Welcome, Andy. Great to have you on. Would love for you to spend a few minutes telling the audience about your background and interests.

Andy Mederich: Excited to be here. Thanks for the invite. I've been at TransUnion for over 22 years and started off in more of a technical role before moving into sales, where I've had a variety of sales roles and sales leadership positions. I run our business development team for the auto business, and our community financial institution business also rolls up into me, so I get a good purview across a lot of different customers.

As for interests: as a Chicago guy, we're all about our sports lately. It's been a great Bears season, and my White Sox kept me entertained this year too.

Let's start off by continuing our conversation from the last quarter. Craig, you noticed a couple of things last quarter. How did they turn out this quarter?

 

Revisiting last quarter's predictions

Craig LaChapelle: Sure, Andy. The item I was actually least sure about is the one that happened. I said watch whether the bigger credit lines issuers were giving super prime customers started moving down the risk spectrum. They did. In the second quarter, opening lines on new cards rose in every risk tier, and the biggest increase went to subprime. So is that a sign issuers feel confident in consumer resilience, or a sign of discipline waning as they compete for growth? The warning light did come on. Whether it's a warning light or just a light is worth some of the discussion today.

Two others I touched on last quarter: I said Federal Housing Administration delinquency would still be an issue, a canary in the coal mine, and I said refinancing would fade if rates stayed in the mid-6s. Rates did more than stay there; they increased. And FHA delinquency is still elevated, so that's something we need to continue to monitor.

Andy Mederich: Rates are a meaty topic, so let's bookmark that and come back to it. Josh, pick it up with you. What materialized from what we thought might happen?

Josh Turnbull: Two of the things we talked about landed. First, I said the FinTech share of personal loan originations wasn't going anywhere, certainly not down. In the last quarter, fintechs essentially made up half of all personal loans. Second, I pointed to the gap between the two measures of delinquency — borrowers delinquent and dollars delinquent — as a vital sign. I said if the dollar measure started to rise, discipline was breaking. It hasn't risen, but the gap between those two things has widened, which is the more interesting result.

Andy Mederich: So if what you're saying is coming true, is it OK if I go tell customers you're geniuses, or should I also warn them?

Josh Turnbull: Probably neither, ideally. It tells you the story has moved. Last quarter we described a market growing carefully at the top end and lending cautiously at the bottom. This quarter, the bottom is really where the growth is, in personal loans and cards. The question is whether the caution came with it as that growth picked up.

 

Two ways to measure delinquency

Andy Mederich: You mentioned that gap between borrower-measured and dollar-measured delinquency. Can you explain that in plain English? Our lenders may misread it.

Josh Turnbull: There are two ways to measure delinquency. You can count the number of people delinquent — what share of borrowers are seriously behind — or you can count dollars: what share of outstanding money is seriously behind. Usually those move together. Right now, they tell opposite stories. In personal loans, the share of borrowers 60 or more days late is just over 4%, the highest for a third quarter since 2010.[VERIFY: CIIR materials report this specific metric at 60+ DPD as 4.12% consumer-level delinquency, highest Q3 since 2010 — figure matches but confirm the exact phrasing of "share of borrowers 60 or more days late."] Compare that to the share of dollars that are late — under 2%, and improved over a year ago.

Andy Mederich: Is that a personal loan quirk?

Craig LaChapelle: No, it's not. Card showed the same split. The share of cardholders 90 days behind is the highest for a third quarter since 2009,[VERIFY: reference materials confirm bankcard consumer-level delinquency rose to 2.50% but don't state "highest since 2009."] while the balance-level rate improved at every stage of delinquency. Even charge-offs show it: more card accounts were written off than a year ago, but the dollars were flat because each one was smaller.

Andy Mederich: If I'm a lender, which metric should I focus on?

Josh Turnbull: The income statement lives in the dollar view, so that's where lenders look. It's also why many large banks reported improving card losses last month. They weren't wrong. But the people view, which is where a lot of headlines gravitate, tells you where the dollar view is heading over time. A customer behind on a small loan is often a customer about to be behind on something larger.

Andy Mederich: Isn't the rise in the people count just what happens when you lend to more smaller, riskier loans?

Josh Turnbull: Partly, and we should say so. Some of the rise is mixed — there are simply more subprime borrowers in the book. But delinquency also rose inside every risk tier. Among subprime personal loan borrowers, the seriously delinquent share went from about 13.5% to nearly 15%.

Craig LaChapelle: And the dollar delinquency figure can mask things. When balances grow quickly, the denominator fills with young loans that haven't had time to go bad. The personal loan charge-off figure that looks so good — down about 11% on the year — is being compared against an unusual spike in the third quarter last year. Look back two years instead, and charge-off dollars are up.

Andy Mederich: So the metrics aren't contradictory. They're just telling two parts of a different story.

Josh Turnbull: That's fair. If I had to pick one place to look, it'd be the earliest stage. The share of personal loan borrowers 30 days delinquent rose more in a single quarter than any other measure in the report. The reassuring part is that it hasn't cascaded: about 70% of those accounts roll forward, the same as last quarter, and cure rates improved slightly. Strain is showing up early, not loss showing up late, yet.

 

Smaller loans, bigger questions

Andy Mederich: Let's quantify what we're seeing lenders do with smaller loans.

Josh Turnbull: In unsecured personal loans, subprime borrowers took out about 42% of new loans in the second quarter but that's only about 12% of dollars outstanding. The average subprime loan shrank by about a tenth, to roughly $2,200. Underneath that, half of new subprime personal loans are now $500 or less. Back in 2019, it was about one in five. Growth is highest among the deepest subprime borrowers.

Andy Mederich: When I hear personal loans, I think debt consolidation. But $500 doesn't sound like a debt consolidation loan.

Josh Turnbull: Exactly. The need is migrating from another type of credit, or it's a new need entirely — rent that came up short, a car that broke down, a gap between paycheck and expense. That type of loan increasingly solves a short-term liquidity problem that's historically been served by a different product.

Andy Mederich: So, a payday loan with a different app behind it?

Josh Turnbull: I'd resist that classification. A small installment loan that amortizes and reports to a credit reporting agency is a different product for most borrowers than a balloon payment or something that rolls over. It's a deliberate risk choice: lenders extend credit to a thinner, riskier file if they cap losses at a few hundred dollars. But it changes what good underwriting looks like. For a loan that small and that short, what happened in a borrower's last 30 days matters a lot more than what happened over the last seven years.

Andy Mederich: How do card issuers fit into this trend toward smaller loans?

Craig LaChapelle: They call it a starter line. It's the card version of the same play. Issuers raised opening lines in every tier, yet the average opening line was flat because a quarter of new cards went to subprime consumers — the highest second-quarter share since at least 2018. What's interesting is who's doing it: the non-prime specialists held their share steady, while the growth came from mainstream issuers widening their buy box.

Andy Mederich: And fintechs in personal loans?

Josh Turnbull: They made about half of all personal loans in the second quarter and accounted for roughly 86% of the growth while banks were flat. One wrinkle: fintechs' recent loans are going bad faster at the account level, even as dollar delinquency improves.

Andy Mederich: Customers often ask me about Gen Z — their personal loan originations rose almost 50%. Is that the story we should be tracking?

Josh Turnbull: It's a headline, but I'm not sure it's the story. Gen Z is the fastest-growing group in nearly every product because millions of them are reaching the age where people start taking out cards and loans. If there's something new, it's that borrowers under about 45 seem to be tilting toward personal loans relative to cards, while older borrowers aren't. I'd want a couple more quarters before calling that a trend.

 

Rising scores, fading tailwind

Andy Mederich: If more people are falling behind in every tier, how has the dollar-level delinquency metric stayed calm for so long?

Josh Turnbull: Consumers had help for three years. After the pandemic, credit scores rose across the population — the median score climbed nearly 20 points between 2019 and 2023 — and that moved borrowers into higher tiers, whether or not anyone changed an underwriting rule. In personal loans, super prime borrowers' share of balances went from about 15% in 2022 to more than 22%. Super prime borrowers rarely default, so as their share of the dollars grew, dollar-weighted delinquency improved almost by itself.

Andy Mederich: What's happening with that trend now?

Josh Turnbull: It's moderated. We see fewer consumers originating loans out of the super prime tier; it's still growing, but the growth rate relative to other tiers has slowed. As more originations come from prime and prime plus, while the median credit score has sat around 712 for three years, you'd naturally expect higher delinquency at the dollar level. Lenders either have to expect that, or sharpen their underwriting and marketing to control for the risk outcome they want.

Andy Mederich: That sounds like bad news dressed up as an observation. How should lenders think about it?

Josh Turnbull: It could be, but it doesn't have to be. When the whole population is drifting upward, it was less important to continually tune underwriting. From here, if performance holds, it'll be because lenders chose well whom to court and approve, and stayed sharp in their decisions. If it doesn't, they won't be entirely to blame — consumers are experiencing the economy differently than they were a few years ago.

Craig LaChapelle: I like the tide analogy. For the last three years, a rising tide let people manage their credit behavior easily. Now that the tide is flat, or even receding, consumers have to dig deeper and invest more time managing their credit. On the growth side: personal loan balances grew about 9%, and close to 90% of the new dollars came from near prime and better borrowers, spread fairly evenly across those tiers. Subprime brings in the borrowers; the middle and the top bring in the money. That's a healthier market than the headlines suggest. It's also a market where the next leg of performance depends on selection, rather than drift or tide.

Andy Mederich: How should a lender address that dynamic?

Craig LaChapelle: Don't just read your overall portfolio delinquency at the top level as proof your strategy is working. Decompose it. How much of the last year's improvement came from consumer scores rising on their own, that rising tide? If the answer is most of it, your strategy hasn't actually been tested in a changing market.

 

Rates and mortgage

Andy Mederich: Back to my bookmark on rates. The Fed raised rates in September, the first time since 2023, and even though it held steady at the last meeting, markets are expecting one more move by December. Craig, what does that do to the mortgage story you told last quarter?

Craig LaChapelle: It closes the window. In the spring, rates dipped enough to bring refinancing back. Second-quarter mortgage originations were up about 13%, the most for a second quarter in four or five years, and refinances climbed to about a fifth of the overall market. Rate-and-term refinancing grew about 60%, down from triple digits the quarter before, and that was before the Fed moved. Now that it has, the Mortgage Bankers Association expects the 30-year rate to average around 7.3% this quarter. Refinancing in large volumes doesn't survive that.

Andy Mederich: Home equity keeps growing, though?

Craig LaChapelle: Nine straight quarters with home equity line of credit (HELOC) originations up about 20%. Same logic as last quarter: if your mortgage is at 3%, you don't touch it, you borrow against the house on top of it. What's different now is that most HELOCs float. Borrowers who opened lines while rates were falling are about to fully feel the impact of a variable rate in a hiking cycle. Given the equity these households hold, I don't expect a credit event, but it's a payment shock, and payment shocks tend to surface in other products first.

Andy Mederich: Last quarter you raised the caution flag on FHA loans. What's happening there?

Craig LaChapelle: Sixty-day mortgage delinquency crossed its 2019 level this quarter, and FHA loans are nearly half of all seriously delinquent mortgage accounts, the largest share in at least 20 years. FHA borrowers are first-time borrowers with thin equity and tight budgets — the people for whom taxes, insurance and now fuel bite hardest. If you want a single place to watch the stretched consumer, this is it.

 

Reading consumer sentiment

Andy Mederich: Unemployment is still around 4.2%, and third-quarter forecasts are strong, but consumer sentiment is close to its lowest point ever. How do I square those two?

Josh Turnbull: It's the same dynamic as dollar versus consumer-level delinquency, applied to the whole economy. Output, employment and bank earnings are dollar-weighted measures; sentiment counts people. October's University of Michigan reading was the second-lowest in the survey's 70-some years, and about seven in 10 consumers expect rates to keep rising. Gasoline is up about a third versus a year ago. If fuel and rent take a larger share of your income, the economy doesn't feel like it's booming. Someone on my team called it a "vibe session," and that's about right.

Andy Mederich: Last quarter you said consumer sentiment is often a leading indicator of credit performance.

Josh Turnbull: I stand by that, with one amendment: the feelings are showing up, but in the people ledger first. That's what the rising delinquency count is.

 

Auto: an affordability story

Andy Mederich: Switching to auto, which is near and dear to my heart. Serious delinquency actually fell this year. Are we ready to declare the affordability crisis over?

Craig LaChapelle: Not even remotely. It's probably the most counterintuitive chart in the report. Delinquency across the whole auto book eased slightly, but the newest loans, made late last year, are performing worse than loans of the same age in 2019, especially among prime and lower-tier borrowers. The book looks better because older, weaker vintages are paying off or charging off. The new ones aren't better.

Andy Mederich: Why would new loans be worse after three years of lessons?

Craig LaChapelle: Because the car got more expensive a lot faster than the paycheck. Since 2019, monthly payments are up about 36% on new cars and 40% on used. Wages are up about 35%, prices generally up about 29%. Consumers absorb the difference by stretching: nearly a quarter of new car loans now run seven years or longer, against about one in seven in 2019.

Josh Turnbull: That's so interesting, Craig. The way they're re-optimizing tells you how tight things are, especially with fuel where it is. We're seeing hybrid and electric registrations rebound, even after the EV tax credit expired. People are doing the math on total cost of ownership, not sticker price, which is rational. It's also a sign of how little slack there is between people's paychecks and their expenses every month.

Andy Mederich: And student loans — what's the latest there?

Josh Turnbull: Still the most distressed corner of the consumer credit market by a wide margin. Nearly 30% of federal student loan borrowers are 90 or more days behind. About one in six have reached default or collections eligibility, which puts wages at risk of garnishment. New federal borrowing caps took effect in July, and Grad PLUS loans are gone, which opens a funding gap and creates an opportunity for private lenders. For listeners who don't lend to students, the point is simple: a borrower whose wages are garnished has less money to go around, for everyone else they owe.

Predictions for next quarter

Andy Mederich: Take out your crystal ball. Give me a few predictions we can test against when we get back together next quarter.

Craig LaChapelle: First, HELOC payments in a rising-rate world, not defaults. I want to look at utilization and minimum payment behavior on lines opened in the last two years, to see how consumers are managing that floating-rate shock. Second, whether mainstream card issuers keep widening the box. The specialists held steady; the big issuers drove the subprime growth. As those new accounts season, consumer-level card delinquency will keep rising, and at some point it stops being only a people story and becomes a balance story. Third, FHA loan performance by metro area. Houston, Atlanta, Tampa and Philadelphia have the highest serious delinquency; Phoenix, St. Louis and Atlanta are rising faster. Let's monitor how those loans perform across regions.

Josh Turnbull: Three for me too. One, whether balance-level delinquency in personal loans really starts to move. It's held at 1.95% for two quarters while borrower-level delinquency has climbed. With the risk mix smaller than it was, you'd expect that to drift upward; if it doesn't, it's likely because scale lenders are continuing to hone their risk strategies. Two, the growth in small-dollar subprime loans of $500 or less. That segment is going to attract regulators and probably fraudsters, as well as competition from fintechs and other lenders. We'll watch how lenders underwrite there and who else moves in. Three, the 30-day bucket. Early delinquency jumped this quarter, but roll rates didn't. If roll rates move off that roughly 70% mark, a consumer-level problem translates to a dollar problem pretty quickly.

Closing takeaways

Andy Mederich: To close it out, one sentence each. What should a lender's executive team take away from this quarter?

Craig LaChapelle: The growth is real and mostly healthy, but some of the good numbers, driven by the macro story of the economy, will be tested going forward.

Josh Turnbull: Look at your borrower-level delinquency as carefully as your dollar-level delinquency. This quarter shows some divergence, which is encouraging, but it's often the consumer-level count that moves first.

Andy Mederich: Josh, Craig, thank you both. I'll be watching your predictions and seeing how they fare against reality next quarter.

Craig LaChapelle: Thanks, Andy. Really appreciate you pushing us and testing us.

Josh Turnbull: Thank you, Andy, for joining us. For those listening, don't forget to subscribe to Extra Credit to catch each new episode when it drops. Search "Extra Credit TransUnion" wherever you get your podcasts and hit subscribe. We'll catch you next time.

Subscribe to Extra Credit

Stay informed on the latest trends shaping financial services, consumer credit and lending. Subscribe to Extra Credit wherever podcasts are available and never miss an episode featuring data-driven insights, market analysis and industry perspectives.

Available On